PREVIEW · not yet accepted by Dr. F · hidden from search
The Museum of Everyday Living · Transportation · Bradenton, FL
TWO SEASONS
Winter, and road construction
In the north they joke that the year has only two seasons. The joke is a fair summary of a hard fact: frost breaks the road all winter, and crews race to fix it in the few warm months. Behind the orange cones sits a question every town argues about: who owns this road, and who pays for it?
WinterWater in the cracks freezes, swells and splits the pavement; salt keeps cars moving and eats the bridges.
Road constructionFrom spring thaw to first frost, every crew and every dollar goes into the short season when asphalt can be laid.
Drawer:Two Seasons: Winter, and Road Construction · Quiz:Two Seasons, 10 questions
Lessons:APMIC 21 · Public goods and the commonsPreviewAPMIC 20 · Externalities (road salt)PreviewAPGOV 6 · Federalism: grants and mandatesPreviewE01 2 · The crossroads and the harborPreviewE22 9 · The readable roadPreview
A road is a stack: a hard skin of asphalt or concrete on layers of crushed stone and soil. Water gets in through hairline cracks. When it freezes it expands by about nine percent, prying the crack wider and lifting the layer above; when it thaws it leaves a void, and the next heavy truck breaks the weakened skin into a pothole. One winter can bring dozens of these cycles, which is why potholes peak in late winter and early spring, not in the deep cold.
Cities fight ice with salt and brine. The U.S. Geological Survey estimates that about 37 percent of all salt used in the country in 2025 went to highway deicing, out of roughly 57 million metric tons consumed. Salt lowers the freezing point of water, but it also rusts steel reinforcing bars inside bridge decks and runs off into streams: a cost the driver never sees, which economists call an externality.
Days below freezing, by state
gap The state map of freezing nights is not drawn yet: NOAA's Comparative Climatic Data station table (mean days with a low of 32°F or colder) has moved and could not be fetched. Until it is loaded, the rule of thumb holds: the northern tier and the mountain West see 120 to 180 freezing nights a year, the Gulf Coast and Florida only a handful, and the road-building season is roughly the frost-free part of the year. Look up any city in NOAA's U.S. Climate Normals.
Go deeper
Lessons:APMIC 20 · Externalities and Pigouvian taxesPreviewAPES 11 · The atmosphere, global winds and climatePreview
Room 2 · Who pays for which roadLocal miles, state money, a federal tax that stood still
The United States has about 4.2 million miles of public road. Most of it is not interstate highway at all: it is county roads, township lanes and city streets. In 2023, local governments owned about 3.2 million miles, state highway agencies about 825,000, and federal agencies (parks, forests, military land) about 159,000. The Interstate System is only about one percent of all road miles, but it carries about a quarter of all driving.
Owner (2023)
Miles
Share
Florida
State highway agencies
824,539
19.6%
12,190
Counties
1,799,886
42.9%
70,914
Towns, townships and cities
1,324,985
31.6%
38,920
Other local and state agencies
90,477
2.2%
89
Federal agencies
159,303
3.8%
2,198
All public roads
4,199,208
100%
124,310
FHWA, Highway Statistics 2023, table HM-10 (rural plus urban; 18 miles unreported). Florida columns from the same table.
The money runs the other way. In 2024 governments spent about $332 billion on highways. States spent 62 percent of it ($206 billion), local governments 36 percent ($121 billion), and federal agencies directly only about 2 percent ($5 billion), because Washington mostly hands its money to the states. Counted by who raises the money, the federal share is larger: about 16 percent, $54 billion, most of it from the Highway Trust Fund.
2024 spending ($ millions)
Federal
State
Local
Total
Capital outlay (building and rebuilding)
595
116,295
42,229
159,119
Maintenance and traffic services
276
35,090
43,028
78,394
Administration and research
3,912
16,999
8,020
28,931
Highway patrol and safety
—
12,806
13,764
26,570
Interest on debt
—
10,092
5,119
15,211
Bond retirement
—
14,933
8,576
23,509
Total
4,783
206,216
120,735
331,734
FHWA, Highway Statistics 2024, table HF-10 (preliminary in part); shares and revenue split from FHWA, Our Nation's Highways 2026. Note that local governments spend more on maintenance than states do: they own the most miles.
The federal gas tax: 18.4 cents since 1993
The federal tax on gasoline has been 18.4 cents a gallon since October 1993 (the last 4.3 cents moved into the Highway Trust Fund in 1997). It is a fixed number of cents, not a percentage, so inflation eats it. Prices have risen about 2.2 times since 1993: today's 18.4 cents buys what about 8.5 cents bought then. Cars also burn less fuel per mile, and electric cars pay none. Since 2008 Congress has moved well over $250 billion from the general fund into the Highway Trust Fund to keep it solvent.
Year set
Cents a gallon
1932
1
1951
2
1956
3
1959
4
1983
9
1990
14.1
1993
18.4
History of the federal motor fuel tax (FHWA; Highway Revenue Act of 1956 created the trust fund). Real value: CPI-U, 1993 dollars; our calculation.
check The "well over $250 billion" in general-fund transfers is a rounded figure from Congressional Budget Office and CRS summaries; check the current total before print.
State gas taxes
AK9¢
ME30¢
VT33¢
NH23.8¢
WA49.4¢
ID33¢
MT33¢
ND23¢
MN31.8¢
IL47¢
WI32.9¢
MI31¢
NY24.6¢
RI37¢
MA24¢
OR40¢
NV23.8¢
WY24¢
SD30¢
IA30¢
IN35¢
OH38.5¢
PA57.6¢
NJ10.5¢
CT52.4¢
CA59.6¢
UT38.5¢
CO22¢
NE30.4¢
MO29.5¢
KY26.4¢
WV35.7¢
VA30.8¢
MD47¢
DE23¢
AZ18¢
NM18.9¢
KS24¢
AR24.7¢
TN27.4¢
NC40.6¢
SC28.8¢
DC23.5¢
OK19¢
LA20¢
MS18.4¢
AL29¢
GA33.1¢
HI16¢
TX20¢
FL37.3¢
under 20¢20–27¢28–35¢36–45¢46¢+
Federation of Tax Administrators, State Motor Fuel Tax Rates (2025), gasoline excise only. Several states add a sales tax on fuel (California, Connecticut, Illinois, Indiana, Michigan) or index the rate to inflation, so the price at the pump can include more. Florida's 37.3¢ includes its state fuel taxes; counties add local option taxes on top.
The 2021 infrastructure law, and what came after
The Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (2021), also called the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, authorized about $1.2 trillion over five years, about $550 billion of it new spending, with roughly $350 billion for highways. Its surface transportation programs expired on September 30, 2026. A short-term extension carries the Highway Trust Fund programs to December 11, 2026, but the extra money the law had appropriated in advance was not extended, and Congress has not yet passed a new long-term highway bill.
Sources: CRS, Surface Transportation Reauthorization: Federal Highway Programs (R48845); NADO, "IIJA Funding Expired September 30" (2026). check status changes quickly; verify before teaching.
Go deeper
Lessons:APGOV 6 · Federalism in action: grants and mandatesPreviewAPMIC 21 · Public goods and the commonsPreviewAPMAC 12 · Fiscal policyPreview
Room 3 · The cost of a mileResurface ten miles, or build one?
Every road budget is a choice between keeping what exists and building more. Florida's Department of Transportation publishes average costs per mile, built from the prices it actually paid contractors. They leave out bridges, intersections, signals and land, so real projects cost more, but they show the scale.
Florida DOT cost-per-mile model
Kind
Cost per mile
Mill and resurface a 2-lane rural road
keep
$0.80 million
Mill and resurface a 4-lane urban road (undivided)
keep
$1.61 million
Mill and resurface a 4-lane urban road (divided)
keep
$1.88 million
Add one lane, rural arterial
widen
$1.17 million
Add one lane, urban arterial
widen
$4.42 million
New 2-lane rural road
build
$5.55 million
New 6-lane rural interstate
build
$15.61 million
New 4-lane urban road
build
$17.02 million
New 4-lane divided urban interstate
build
$23.89 million
New 6-lane divided urban interstate
build
$25.79 million
Florida Department of Transportation, Cost Per Mile Models (latest edition, weighted averages of awarded prices from about 18 months before the update). Rounded to $0.01 million. Conceptual: excludes structures, right-of-way, intersections and signals.
For the price of one mile of new urban interstate, a county could resurface about thirty miles of two-lane road. That is why so much of the warm season goes to milling and resurfacing: it is the cheapest way to keep the most miles open.
Bridges
The National Bridge Inventory rates every public bridge longer than 20 feet. Under the old measure, "structurally deficient" bridges fell from 21.7% of all bridges in 1992 (124,072 of 572,629) to 13.1% in 2005 and 8.9% in 2017. Since 2018 the inventory rates bridges good, fair or poor by their weakest part. In the inventory file Urbanicity holds (624,193 bridges), 6.7% are rated poor, 49.6% fair and 43.7% good.
AK7.5%
ME15.4%
VT4%
NH7.5%
WA5.6%
ID5.4%
MT7.4%
ND11.1%
MN4.5%
IL9.5%
WI6.7%
MI11%
NY9.9%
RI14%
MA9.4%
OR5.1%
NV1%
WY7.1%
SD16.1%
IA18.6%
IN5.3%
OH4.7%
PA12.1%
NJ5.7%
CT4.8%
CA4.9%
UT3.5%
CO4.6%
NE7.5%
MO8.8%
KY7.5%
WV17.8%
VA3.4%
MD4.4%
DE1.1%
AZ1.1%
NM4.3%
KS5.2%
AR5.4%
TN4.4%
NC7.1%
SC6.3%
DC1.9%
OK7.5%
LA11.2%
MS5.8%
AL3.4%
GA1.7%
HI5.7%
TX1.2%
FL2.8%
under 3% poor3–4.9%5–7.9%8–11.9%12%+
Share of bridges rated poor, by state: Bureau of Transportation Statistics, National Transportation Atlas Database, National Bridge Inventory layer as loaded by Urbanicity. Poor = lowest of deck, superstructure, substructure or culvert rated 4 or less.
Go deeper
Lesson:APMIC 1 · Scarcity and opportunity costPreview
Room 4 · Where roads meet ships and trainsIntermodal nodes and ports
Roads do not end at the coast. A container can cross the Pacific by ship, ride a train to Chicago and finish the trip on a truck without being opened. The places where freight changes mode are intermodal terminals: ports with rail spurs to the dock, and inland yards where cranes lift containers and trailers between trains and trucks. The map shows the 150 principal ports by the weight of cargo they handled in 2023, and the rail-truck terminals the Bureau of Transportation Statistics lists.
Lower 48 only (Alaska, Hawaii and Puerto Rico ports are in the table). Ports: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Principal Ports (2023 tonnage, BTS National Transportation Atlas Database). Terminals: BTS, Intermodal Freight Facilities, rail TOFC/COFC (240 shown).
#
Port (2023)
Total short tons
Foreign
Domestic
1
Houston Port Authority, TX
309,531,236
229,019,431
80,511,805
2
South Louisiana, LA, Port of
217,531,611
108,400,804
109,130,807
3
Corpus Christi, TX
189,775,751
163,695,289
26,080,462
4
New York, NY & NJ
132,289,509
89,870,204
42,419,305
5
Beaumont, TX
87,879,130
60,943,610
26,935,520
6
Port of Long Beach, CA
85,260,786
72,575,928
12,684,858
7
New Orleans, LA
75,385,883
35,572,247
39,813,636
8
Port of Greater Baton Rouge, LA
73,041,412
27,258,294
45,783,118
9
Virginia, VA, Port of
68,766,562
64,740,681
4,025,881
10
Lake Charles Harbor District, LA
64,163,423
40,170,169
23,993,254
11
Port of Los Angeles, CA
55,378,332
52,467,050
2,911,282
12
Mobile, AL
52,180,346
36,449,463
15,730,883
18
Tampa Port Authority, FL
32,018,524
12,656,426
19,362,098
73
Manatee County Port, FL
5,311,740
4,297,789
1,013,951
Close to home. Port Manatee, on Tampa Bay just north of Bradenton, bills itself as the closest U.S. deepwater seaport to the Panama Canal; it handles fruit juice, fertilizer, steel, cement, containers and fuel, has its own rail line to the national network, and sits minutes from I-75 and I-275. Port Tampa Bay, Florida's largest port by tonnage, moves fuel, phosphate and fertilizer for the region. Every truck that leaves either port uses roads that a county, the state or the federal government had to build and still has to keep.
Go deeper
Lessons:E01 2 · The crossroads and the harborPreviewE22 9 · The readable roadPreview
Room 5 · The long runMiles built, roads maintained
The road network barely grew in length over the last century, from about 3 million miles around 1920 to 4.2 million today. What changed was what those miles are made of and who keeps them. In 1941 fewer than one mile in five was paved; by 2007 about two in three were. The rail network went the other way: from its 1916 peak of 254,037 route miles it shrank to about 140,000. Pick a year to compare.
Thousands of miles. Paved road miles start in 1941 (HM-212) and stop at 2007, when the surface-type count changed. Rail: Series Q 284; 1975+ rounded.
All public road miles, total and paved
1900 and 1918 rounded (FHWA); 1921–1940 HM-210; 1941–1995 HM-212; 1996–2007 BTS NTS 1-4; 2023 HM-10. Before 1980 totals include some roads not open to the public.
Interstate miles open to traffic
FHWA status of the Interstate System, 1960–1997; 2024 from Our Nation's Highways 2026. The system kept adding routes after 1997, so 2024 is not the original plan.
Who controls the miles (thousands)
HM-210 (1921–1995), HM-10 (2000, 2023). "Federal" is roads in federal parks, forests and reservations; the definition of state control shifted in some years as states took over or returned roads.
Highway spending by level of government, 2024 dollars
HF-210 (1921–1970) and HF-10 (2000, 2010, 2024), deflated with the CPI-U (our calculation). 1980 and 1990 are not keyed yet: the gap in the bars is missing data, not zero. Federal here is direct federal spending only; most federal money is spent by states.
Building vs maintaining, 2024 dollars
Capital outlay and maintenance, all governments: HF-210, FHWA Our Nation's Highways 2000 (1975–1995), HF-10. CPI-U deflator understates construction-cost inflation in the 1970s.
Decade by decade
Year
Public road miles
Paved
Lane-miles
Interstate open
Rail route miles
Spending, 2024 $ bn
Bridges deficient/poor
1920
3,160,000 (1921)
—
—
none
252,845
24.3
—
1930
3,259,000
—
—
none
249,052
53.6
—
1940
3,287,000
—
—
none
—
60.2
—
1950
3,312,975
779,997
—
none
223,779
58.1
—
1960
3,545,693
1,230,469
—
10,440
217,552
114.0
—
1970
3,730,082
1,658,421
—
31,543
199,000 (1975)
168.4
—
1980
3,859,837
2,072,692
7,922,174
40,253
199,000 (1975)
cap+maint 120.9
—
1990
3,866,926
2,254,822
8,051,081
42,532
172,000 (1995)
cap+maint 133.2
21.7% (1992)
2000
3,950,000
2,504,000
8,224,245
42,787 (1997)
172,000 (1995)
232.2
13.1% (2005)
2010
4,047,000 (2007)
2,635,000
8,581,158
—
—
295.4
8.9% (2017)
2023
4,199,208
—
8,908,761
48,830 (2024)
140,000 (2025)
331.7
6.7% poor
Lane-miles: BTS NTS table 1-6 (1980–2014), HM-60 (2023). Added per decade: 1980s about 129,000; 1990s about 173,000; 2000s about 357,000; 2010–2023 about 328,000. A year in brackets means the nearest year with data. Bridge measures changed in 2018 (structurally deficient → poor), so the last column breaks there.
Go deeper
Lesson:APMIC 21 · Public goods and the commonsPreview
Why are potholes worst in March rather than January?
Local governments own about three-quarters of all road miles but spend about a third of the money. Who pays the rest, and why does that matter for a small county?
The federal gas tax has not risen since 1993. Name two ways to fix the Highway Trust Fund and one group that would object to each.
A county has $8 million. Using the cost table, compare resurfacing with building. Which would you choose, and what would you tell the people on the waiting list?
Find Port Manatee on the map. Trace one shipment of orange juice concentrate from the dock to a grocery store in Ohio. Which modes and which owners of road or rail does it touch?
Rail route miles fell by about 45 percent since 1916 while paved road miles quadrupled after 1941. What happened to towns that lost their depot but gained a paved highway?
Federation of Tax Administrators, State Motor Fuel Tax Rates (2025): taxadmin.org
U.S. Geological Survey, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026, Salt: pubs.usgs.gov
NOAA NCEI, Comparative Climatic Data (mean days with minimum 32°F or less) and U.S. Climate Normals: ncei.noaa.gov (state freeze map pending; see Room 1).
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Principal Ports, 2023 tonnage (BTS NTAD); Houston Ship Channel 2023 ranking: txgulf.org
CRS R48845, Surface Transportation Reauthorization: everycrsreport.com; NADO on the IIJA expiration: nado.org
Rail route miles: Historical Statistics of the United States, Series Q 284, as on Rails, Spurs and the Truck. Consumer price index: BLS CPI-U annual averages.